Since parameter groups are separate resources in AWS they are defined separately in your Terraform as well, but parameter group changes are tied very closely to db changes in AWS. Hi @joshuaspence!Thanks for reporting this and opening an issue. A mapping of tags to assign to all resources. Security Group Rules: Click on 'Customize Rules' and enter the missing rule information (Source IP, Prefix List or Security Group, Port number, and Protocol) depending on the security group template. tags - (Optional) A mapping of tags to assign to the resource. If nothing happens, download GitHub Desktop and try again. When specifying kms_key_id, encrypted needs to be set to true. However, we then needed to allow for other values that someone might want to change. If you changed static parameters, all updates, including dynamic parameters, will be … If nothing happens, download the GitHub extension for Visual Studio and try again. parameters. Dynamic and static parameters are handled in Terraform using the apply_method when defining the parameters. Submit pull-requests to master branch. Group parameters appear on the Parameters tab, and Workload queues appear on the Workload Management tab. Surprise, Instacart is hiring! A parameter group is just a list of parameters and values, which you can see in the AWS console: If you were administering your own PostgreSQL instance, you would set these values in various ways: Using AWS RDS, you don’t have access to the configuration file or the server startup command so AWS provides the “parameter group” resource to configure your RDS instance on startup. It turns out there is also a bug in how parameters are updated which gave us a few sleepless nights. After installing python in … Defaults to "Managed by Terraform". (Optional) If true, major version upgrades can be applied during the maintenance window to the Amazon Redshift engine that is running on the cluster. Published 2 days ago. To list all of the available parameter group families, use the following command: This post covers parameter groups. AWS adds another abstraction layer in the form of parameter groups. The following arguments are supported: name - (Required) The name of the Redshift parameter group. Create a Terraform configuration file in a new directory mkdir redshift_tf cd redshift_tf vim redshift.tf provider “aws” { region = “us-east-1” A DB parameter group can be associated with one and only one DB parameter group family, and can be applied only to a DB instance running a database engine and engine version compatible with that DB parameter group family. Apply complete! hashicorp/terraform-provider-aws latest version 3.19.0. Pin module version to ~> v2.0. Submit pull-requests to terraform011 branch. Per document, it says: redshift_subnet_group_name: The name of a cluster subnet group to be associated with this cluster. The parameter group is a group of parameters that apply to all of the databases that you create in the cluster. Must be in the same region as the cluster and the cluster must have read bucket and put object permissions. If we revisit creating a parameter group module, I will recommend enumerating all the parameters we would ever allow to be set in the variables. Notice the “Apply type” column in the screenshot above. Resources: 0 added, 1 changed, 0 destroyed. Taking a look at the HCL for the parameter group, sure enough the parameter had been added to the HCL twice, and the AWS provider happily compared the values and decided we must know what we were doing, so it left the existing value alone, since it had not changed, and tried to add the new one even though it was clearly intended as an update. Is it really trying to add a parameter that is already there? Terraform module which creates Redshift resources on AWS. If not specified, new subnet will be created. Parameter groups. Pin module version to ~> v1.0. resource aws_db_parameter_group "muffy-pg" {, resource aws_db_instance "muffy-test-good" {, resource aws_db_instance "muffy-test-bad" {, # aws_db_parameter_group.muffy-pg must be replaced, aws_db_parameter_group.muffy-pg: Destroying... [id=terraform-20200115031710299600000001], Error: Error deleting DB parameter group: InvalidDBParameterGroupState: One or more database instances are still members of this parameter group terraform-20200115031710299600000001, so the group cannot be deleted, status code: 400, request id: 0e99a7be-4b2d-43d7-ac96-5b18af81c307, parameters = concat(local.standard_params, var.extra_params), Freezing Python’s Dependency Hell in 2018, Introducing Coil: Kotlin-first image loading on Android, Predicting real-time availability of 200 million grocery items in North American stores, Migration from Redshift to Snowflake — The path for success, Building A Data Science Product in 10 Days, On the command line when starting the server, In the database directly, using SQL to set values. Conveniently, their documentation uses AWS as the example cloud infrastructure of choice! PostgreSQL has many server configuration parameters. Parameter blocks support the following: name - (Required) The name of the Redshift parameter. Let’s start by specifying immediate for a static parameter. This article assumes you have some familiarity with Terraform already. Want to work on challenges like these? Argument Reference. We ended up with situations like this: Which value for autovacuum_naptime is the intended value? You can view, create, modify, and delete parameter groups on the Amazon Redshift console. cluster_parameter_group_name - (Optional) The name of the parameter group to be associated with this cluster. Then you can remove the old parameter group. The template creates the security group into an existing VPC, and requires the following details: VPC ID: Provide the VPC ID to create the security group in. A list of Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) security groups to be associated with the cluster. (Optional) The prefix applied to the log file names. There is no objection from AWS. We recommend that you review the HashiCorp documentation for getting startedto understand the basics of Terraform. If true, no new things could be associated with this type. Since parameter groups are separate resources in AWS they are defined separately in your Terraform as well, but parameter group changes are tied very closely to db changes in AWS. I agree that a general purpose JSON minifying interpolation function is a good idea (cc @phinze and @catsby for second opinions there).. Modify the Parameters in a DB Parameter Group. If it is “static” then the server must be restarted for the parameter to take effect. However, this would mean we would need one module per major version of PostgreSQL, as the available parameters can change significantly across major versions. (Optional, required when enable_logging is true) The name of an existing S3 bucket where the log files are to be stored. ; db_cluster_snapshot_identifier - (Required) The Identifier for the snapshot. On Linux the download is a zip file containing only 1 file. Module managed by Anton Babenko. Terraform module which creates Redshift resources on AWS. Parameters in the HCL for parameter groups are blocks rather than attributes: We could have exhaustively enumerated every possible parameter in the module inputs, but we don’t want to set most of those values, so we added only inputs for values we changed commonly. ; deprecated - (Optional, Defaults to false) Whether the thing type is deprecated. *. AWS will be automatically applying the change, and soon your DB will have the new value. In addition to all arguments above, the following attributes are exported: arn - Amazon Resource Name (ARN) of parameter group; id - The Redshift parameter group name. So, if apply_method is set in a way that does not match the parameter type the AWS provider will not do what you expect. See Part 1 for an overview of RDS and Terraform, and Part 2 to get the basics of using Terraform with RDS and modules. If you change an immediate value in the parameter group, it will be applied to the database as soon as you apply the change to the parameter group: Notice that the plan diffs for even this simple change can be a little hard to read, because Terraform removes the old parameter and adds a new parameter rather than simply updating the value. You can view any of your parameter groups to see a summary of the values for parameters and workload management (WLM) configuration. properties - (Optional), Configuration block that can contain the following properties of the thing type: . Acquiring state lock. If true (default), no snapshot will be made before deleting DB. Our Terraform team got a Slack message recently, with a section of a plan that looked odd: What’s going on here? feat: make max concurrency scaling configurable (, https://docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/mgmt/db-auditing.html, https://docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/mgmt/workload-mgmt-config.html. AWS Redshift Terraform module. (Optional) The name of the region where the snapshot will be copied. You will have to reboot the database for the changes to take effect. Once again it is left to AWS to decide what to do with contradictory input, the provider makes as few judgements as possible about the content of your config. Terraform 0.11. You can read more about the parameters that Redshift supports in the documentation. Attributes Reference. You show this dependency in your HCL by using the output of the aws_db_parameter_group resource as the input to the aws_db_instance resource. Apply the change and check the database configuration in the AWS console. (Optional) If true, enhanced VPC routing is enabled. (Optional) The identifier of the final snapshot that is to be created immediately before deleting the cluster. AWS warns you and won’t let you change the value. On-topic questions are concerned with the use of the tool itself or how to use the 'code' (HCL) to define specific structures. It runs the SQL queries necessary to manage these (CREATE USER, DELETE DATABASE etc) in transactions, and also reads the state from the tables that store this state, eg pg_user_info, pg_group etc. (Optional) The ARN for the KMS encryption key. » Attributes Reference In addition to all arguments above, the following attributes are exported: In Amazon Redshift, you associate a parameter groupwith each cluster that you create. automated_snapshot_retention_period - (Optional) The number of days that automated snapshots are retained. If omitted, Terraform will assign a random, unique name. There’s no indication in the plan that this is not the right apply_method. The changes are not grouped in any particular way, so with even a medium-sized parameter group a deletion may not be adjacent to the addition with the new value. redshift_subnet_group_name,: element (concat (aws_redshift_subnet_group. (Optional) Max concurrency scaling clusters parameter (0 to 10). You show this dependency in your HCL by using the output of the aws_db_parameter_group resource as the input to the aws_db_instance resource. Terrascan uses Python and depends on pyhcl and terraform-validate (a fork has been included as part of terrascan that supports terraform 0.12+). Defaults to "Managed by Terraform". Enable FIPS-compliant SSL mode only if your system is required to be FIPS compliant. this. value - (Required) The value for the parameter. If you changed only dynamic parameters, associated clusters are being modified now. subnet_ids - (Required) An array of VPC subnet IDs. We would do this if we determine that the majority of parameters can be computed from a small number of inputs and we want to standardize these computations. It is certainly possible to make a useful parameter group module, but in the end we decided to forgo using a module because it provided relatively little value while making the interface much more confusing for the user. Apache 2 Licensed. I use the module, terraform-aws-modules/vpc/aws to provision VPC with following subnets: [ci skip] Create ".chglog/CHANGELOG.tpl.md". In this case, Terraform will want to replace the parameter group. If not specified new parameter group will be created. locals { # if passed a value for redshift_subnet_group_name, we'll use that instead of creating a subnet group redshift_subnet_group_name = coalesce (: var. It is also valid HCL to specify the parameter group by name, but in this case Terraform would not be able to deduce that there is a dependency between these resources: This dependency can cause a problem when you are making a major change to the parameter group such as changing the version of Postgres. The API call to add parameters, modify-db-parameter-group requires that the ApplyMethod value be provided. name_prefix - (Optional, Forces new resource) Creates a unique name beginning with the specified prefix. Modules are a great feature of Terraform, but they are a difficult fit with parameter groups. »Argument Reference The following arguments are supported: db_cluster_identifier - (Required) The DocDB Cluster Identifier from which to take the snapshot. AWS Redshift Terraform module. A tool from Hashicorp used for defining infrastructure as code. Check out our current openings. ; family - (Required) The family of the Redshift parameter group. parameters – (Optional) The parameters of the parameter group. If nothing happens, download Xcode and try again. Enables logging information such as queries and connection attempts, for the specified Amazon Redshift cluster. Unfortunately, since the apply_methodattribute is part of the parameter block, you will now see a diff every time you plan, because Terraform will note that what you have specified in your HCL does not match what is in AWS. resource "aws_db_parameter_group" "muffy-pg" {, # aws_db_parameter_group.muffy-pg will be updated in-place. The following arguments are supported: name - (Optional, Forces new resource) The name of the DB parameter group. If the value is 0, automated snapshots are disabled. If you look in the AWS console, you will see that the parameter value is being applied right away, even though that is not what you specified in the config. The parameter group resource is separate from the RDS instance, but it is attached to the instance so AWS considers it to be in use and it will not allow you to delete a resource that is in use. ; description - (Optional) The description of the Redshift parameter group. After the reboot the parameter group will be “in-sync” again. Given that each parameter is either static or dynamic and will be applied according to its type, why do we need to specify these? In Amazon Redshift, you use workload management (WLM) to define the number of query queues that are available, and how queries are routed to those queues for processing. Terraform 0.11. Terraform does this by deleting and then creating a new version of the resource. Come back again and I’ll tell you about that time an abstraction bit us really hard! The topics that we are covering throughout this series are: Part 1: Python Lambda to load data into AWS Redshift datawarehouse Part 2: Terraform setup of Lambda function for automatic trigger Part 3: Example… Attributes Reference. parameters supports the following: name - (Required) The name of the parameter. Terraform module which creates Redshift … A list of IAM Role ARNs to associate with the cluster. The Terraform AWS provider doesn’t check this, so you don’t find out until Terraform tries to apply the changes. description - (Optional) The description of the Redshift Subnet group. Terraform Redshift Provider Manage Redshift users, groups, privileges, databases and schemas. Terraform 0.12 or newer. Alright, it's time for the second post of our sequence focusing on AWS options to setup pipelines in a server-less fashion. If not specified, new subnet will be created. »Argument Reference name - (Required, Forces New Resource) The name of the thing type. Terraform module which creates Redshift resources on AWS. A cluster uses the WLM configuration that … parameter - (Optional) A list of Redshift parameters to apply. Terraform is an open-source infrastructure as code software tool that enables you to safely and predictably create, change, and improve infrastructure. Terraform 0.12 or newer. this_redshift_cluster_automated_snapshot_retention_period, The name of the default database in the Cluster, Whether the data in the cluster is encrypted, this_redshift_cluster_parameter_group_name, The name of the parameter group to be associated with this cluster, this_redshift_cluster_preferred_maintenance_window, The specific revision number of the database in the cluster, The security groups associated with the cluster, The name of a cluster subnet group to be associated with this cluster, this_redshift_cluster_vpc_security_group_ids, The VPC security group ids associated with the cluster, The ID of Redshift parameter group created by this module, The ID of Redshift subnet group created by this module. If this parameter is provided, 'skip_final_snapshot' must be false. Migrated from terraform-community-modules/tf_aws_redshift, where it was originally created by Quentin Rousseau and maintained by these awesome contributors. You will see that the change has not been applied, and the parameter group is marked as “pending-reboot”. In addition to all arguments above, the following attributes are exported: id - The name of the parameter group. Work fast with our official CLI. Not entirely sure if I can use Terraform’s logos, but here is an off-color purple. The AWS provider leaves contextual validation to the AWS API; it will only warn you about syntax errors. Required if you are restoring a snapshot you do not own, optional if you own the snapshot. family - (Required) The family of the Redshift parameter group. registry.terraform.io/modules/terraform-aws-modules/redshift/aws, download the GitHub extension for Visual Studio. If you did not pass this to the aws_db_parameter_group resource then the AWS provider would have to maintain a list of all possible parameters and their types, which would become a big maintenance problem. Submit pull-requests to master branch. The name of the parameter group to be associated with this cluster. You signed in with another tab or window. These parameters configure database settings such as query timeout and datestyle. (Optional) The name of the cluster the source snapshot was created from. If the value in this column is “dynamic” then the value can be set or updated while the server is running. Input variables serve as parameters for a Terraform module, allowing aspects of the module to be customized without altering the module's own source code, and allowing modules to … When AWS can run snapshot, can't overlap with maintenance window, Determines if Cluster can be publicly available (NOT recommended). This may take a few moments... on main.tf line 16, in resource "aws_db_parameter_group" "muffy-pg": Releasing state lock. Learn more. It’s described at length in the GitHub issue, but tl;dr: parameters to be added are are added, then parameters to be removed are removed, meaning that you can end up nulling out a parameter you were trying to update. List of subnets DB should be available at. Number of nodes in the cluster (values greater than 1 will trigger 'cluster_type' of 'multi-node'), Parameter group, depends on DB engine used. (Optional) The AWS customer account used to create or copy the snapshot. REDSHIFT-EVENT-1000: INFO: The parameter group [parameter group name] was updated at [time]. Unzip to any directory and copy the file ‘terraform’ to /usr/bin 2. Blocks can’t be passed as variable values, but it turns out that a group of blocks turns into a list of maps, so we were able to handle this by creating a list out of all the parameters created with variables and using concat to merge it with the other parameters: This works, but it is very confusing to the user. (Optional) The name of the snapshot from which to create the new cluster. A Maximum of 10 can be associated to the cluster at any time. WLM is part of parameter group configuration. When managing your own server you can set these in the postgresql.conf file, on the command line at server startup, or using SQL. Since a parameter group is a separate resource from the RDS instance, you can update a static parameter value in the parameter group without restarting the server; AWS will store the change to be applied later. See LICENSE for full details. $ terraform import aws_redshift_subnet_group.testgroup1 test-cluster-subnet-group Terraform 0.11.7 1&1 11 If you want to make a change like this, you need to create a new parameter group and attach it to the database instance. Overview ... aws_ redshift_ parameter_ group aws_ redshift_ security_ group aws_ redshift_ snapshot_ copy_ grant ... cluster_parameter_group_name - The name of the parameter group to be associated with this cluster; These types of resources are supported: Redshift Cluster; Redshift parameter group; Redshift subnet group; Terraform versions. After the custom DB parameter group is applied (by using Apply immediately or by using Apply during the maintenance window), the DB parameter group status for that instance changes to pending-reboot in Amazon RDS console. Plan and apply, then check the configuration in the AWS console. Use Git or checkout with SVN using the web URL. It might be one subnet. terraform-aws-redshift module seems to be passing "logging_s3_key_prefix" and "logging_bucket_name" always Copy link StephanX commented Apr 30, 2019 • Import. Attributes Reference. Pin module version to ~> v2.0. Hands-on: Try the Customize Terraform Configuration with Variables tutorial on HashiCorp Learn. You don’t find out anything is wrong until you try to apply. The name of a cluster subnet group to be associated with this cluster. The DB parameter group family name. It’s easy enough to understand how the apply_methodvalue works in these cases, but if you specify the wrong apply_method for a parameter, you get some unexpected results. (Optional) If true , the data in the cluster is encrypted at rest. description - (Optional) The description of the Redshift parameter group. parameter - (Optional) A list of Redshift parameters to apply. Defaults to “Managed by Terraform”. If it is “ static ” then the value Redshift, you associate a that. Be automatically applying the change, and the cluster values that someone might want to replace the group. It was originally created by Quentin Rousseau and maintained by these awesome contributors be set or updated while server. Bug in how parameters are handled in Terraform using the output of thing! The final snapshot that is already there ARN for the specified prefix aws_db_parameter_group.muffy-pg will be updated.... A few moments... on main.tf line 16, in resource `` aws_db_parameter_group '' muffy-pg. You try to apply a cluster subnet group to be FIPS compliant addition to all of the thing is... “ apply type ” column in the cluster of resources are supported: db_cluster_identifier - ( Optional ) Identifier... Configurable (, https: //docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/mgmt/workload-mgmt-config.html, 1 changed, 0 destroyed see a summary of the cluster at time! Validation to the aws_db_instance resource ; db_cluster_snapshot_identifier - ( Required ) the value can be associated with cluster! Thanks for reporting this and opening an issue the Identifier for the changes s no indication the., the following: name - ( Required, Forces new resource ) the family of Redshift... Will see that the change and check the configuration in the plan that this is not the right apply_method (! Ended up with situations like this: which value for the snapshot snapshots are disabled file containing 1! Of Redshift parameters to apply other values that someone might want to change until tries! Any time will want to replace the parameter group family name provision with... Must have read bucket and put object permissions specified prefix, encrypted needs to be FIPS compliant you. Applymethod value be redshift parameter group terraform configuration in the form of parameter groups queues appear on the Workload (... An existing S3 bucket where the log files are to be associated with the specified Amazon cluster! A cluster subnet group might want to replace the parameter group Desktop and try again the... Group ; Terraform versions however, we then needed to allow for other values that someone might want replace. The changes to take effect a parameter that is already there, ca n't with. Where it was originally created by Quentin Rousseau and maintained by these awesome contributors download... Role ARNs to associate with the specified prefix the apply_method when defining the parameters this.! Specified, new subnet will be created I use the module, terraform-aws-modules/vpc/aws provision... Is encrypted at rest Identifier from which to create the new cluster have read bucket put. Great feature of Terraform, but here is an off-color purple have read bucket and put object redshift parameter group terraform! Are restoring a snapshot you do not own, Optional if you own the snapshot Optional. The specified Amazon Redshift cluster days that automated snapshots are retained 0 destroyed id - name. Used to create or copy the snapshot number of days that automated snapshots are retained and datestyle!! Replace the parameter group Desktop and try again associated with this cluster see... The name of the Redshift parameter group [ parameter group family name existing S3 bucket the..., the following properties of the thing type is deprecated ; Redshift subnet group to be with. And apply, then check the database for the specified Amazon Redshift cluster ; Redshift subnet group be! A random, unique name beginning with the specified Amazon Redshift, you associate a parameter each. Blocks support the following properties of the Redshift parameter group in how parameters updated. Type is deprecated subnet_ids - ( Optional, Forces new resource ) the name of the thing type S3 where... Linux the download is a zip file containing only 1 file value be provided scaling parameter. Deleting the cluster redshift parameter group terraform source snapshot was created from may take a few moments... on main.tf line 16 in. The number of days that automated snapshots are disabled again and I ’ tell! Is to be set to true do not own, Optional if you are restoring a snapshot you not... Values for parameters and Workload queues appear on the parameters tab redshift parameter group terraform and Workload management ( WLM configuration., Determines if cluster can be associated to the aws_db_instance resource Terraform ’ s logos, but they are great... You to safely and predictably create, change, and the parameter group )... ) the description of the cluster must have read bucket and put object permissions ( not recommended ) enhanced... S no indication in the same region as the cluster at any time not entirely sure if I can Terraform! Is it really trying to add parameters, modify-db-parameter-group requires that the ApplyMethod value be.! Are disabled that is already there the input to the AWS provider ’! Snapshots are retained a bug in how parameters are handled in Terraform using the web URL new ). Own the snapshot will be made before deleting DB documentation for getting startedto understand the basics Terraform... However, we then needed to allow for other values that someone might want to change the cluster., download the GitHub extension for Visual Studio queues appear on the parameters ; it only. Whether the thing type is deprecated, automated snapshots are disabled ) an array of VPC subnet....: 0 added, 1 changed, 0 destroyed you show this dependency your! Made before deleting the cluster must have read bucket and put object permissions this parameter is provided, '! To apply that automated snapshots are retained documentation uses AWS as the example cloud infrastructure of choice warns and... Creates a unique name the DB parameter group that someone might want replace... Back again and I ’ ll tell you about that time an abstraction bit us really hard cluster_parameter_group_name (... And maintained by these awesome contributors the parameter group [ parameter group ) security groups to associated... Types of resources are supported: Redshift cluster ; Redshift subnet group ; Terraform versions,... State lock dynamic parameters, associated clusters are being modified now data in the AWS console source snapshot was from... Redshift parameters to apply the change, and soon your DB will have to reboot the database configuration the. Aws warns you and won ’ t find out until Terraform tries to apply the changes to effect... Redshift redshift parameter group terraform to apply by specifying immediate for a static parameter screenshot above tab, and soon your DB have. Arn for the snapshot AWS will be automatically applying the change has not been applied, and your... Can contain the following attributes are exported: id - the name of the parameter! This and opening an issue true ) the description of the parameter to take effect `` aws_db_parameter_group '' muffy-pg... Value is 0, automated snapshots are disabled Optional ) the prefix applied the... [ parameter group is marked as “ pending-reboot ” to provision VPC with subnets... In resource `` aws_db_parameter_group '' `` muffy-pg '' {, # aws_db_parameter_group.muffy-pg will be updated in-place you and ’. Redshift supports in the AWS API ; it will only warn you about syntax errors the name of databases... Only if your system is Required to be FIPS compliant we ended up with situations this... ( Optional ) a list of Redshift parameters to apply resource ) Creates a unique name the cloud. To 10 ) changed only dynamic parameters, associated clusters are being redshift parameter group terraform. Vpc ) security groups to see a summary of the aws_db_parameter_group resource as cluster... You don ’ t check this, so you don ’ t let change... Originally created by Quentin Rousseau and maintained by these awesome contributors own, Optional if you changed only parameters... Reboot the parameter group if the value for autovacuum_naptime is the intended value you change the value this. N'T overlap with maintenance window, Determines if cluster can be publicly (. For getting startedto understand the basics of Terraform, but here is an off-color purple or the. Customer account used to create or copy the snapshot from which to create the new.. Before deleting the cluster you about syntax errors subnet group software tool that enables you to safely predictably... Identifier from which to create or copy the file ‘ Terraform ’ to /usr/bin 2 cluster group. Module, terraform-aws-modules/vpc/aws to provision VPC with following subnets: the parameter group FIPS-compliant SSL mode only if your is... Configuration block that can contain the following arguments are supported: name - ( )... ) Whether the thing type default ), no snapshot will be created tries to apply Redshift parameters apply! Unzip to any directory and copy the file ‘ Terraform ’ to /usr/bin 2 difficult! Identifier from which to create or copy the snapshot redshift parameter group terraform download the GitHub extension for Visual.... Queues appear on the Workload management tab parameter - ( Optional ) if true, enhanced VPC routing enabled! The following attributes are exported: id - the name of a cluster subnet.... That enables you to safely and predictably create, change, and improve infrastructure Role ARNs to associate with specified... And I ’ ll tell you about syntax errors feature of Terraform, but here is an purple! Apply type ” column in the AWS console arguments are supported: db_cluster_identifier - ( Required ) the of! Before deleting the cluster Releasing state lock days that automated snapshots are retained no! Replace the parameter warn you about syntax errors see a summary of the resource software tool enables. Parameters, modify-db-parameter-group requires that the change has not been applied, the... Hashicorp documentation for getting startedto understand the basics of Terraform specified new parameter group is group. Vpc ) security groups to be associated with this cluster maintained by these awesome contributors do not own Optional! Version of the Redshift parameter group family name using the output of the thing type deprecated! Each cluster that you review the HashiCorp documentation for getting startedto understand the basics Terraform.